Bruce,

I went back and checked again and found you and both made mistakes. I must have copied one formula wrong. Here is yours: In the 3 Day above you had Stoc 42.16 which omited a decimal and should be 42.1.6. Now all is matching.

Thanks for the help.

Rod

Bruce,

I did exactly that today and have discrepancies. I copied your formulas into two PCFs yesterday and still have yesterday's charts as I update after the market close. I also yesterday put the Sochastics 14,5,1 and 14,5,3 into the top view. Today I added the columns you suggested. For symbol WLL it shows in the pop up box  82.38 for 14,5,3 and 81.72 for 14,5,1 and in the columns 81.60 for 14,5,3 and 72.33 for 14,5,1. I have no idea what I have done wrong as I copied your formulas with my mouse and double checked everthing. Also I tested the PCFs. At least the SK and SD are still in relative positions.

Rod

Thanks Bruce,

I actually had tried tho simple formulas you wrote. But I did not get an exact match with the pop up box for the 14,5,3. On WLL for 1/24/17 I has a 0.20 discrepancy. But for the 14,5 I have a 1.46 discrepancy.

Rod

Stochastic for a 3 day setting in Version 7. I need help to create a crossing scan for the stochastic 14,5,3 for a 3 day chart. Every method I try does not me the same answer that I get for the stochastic in the pop up box in the top chart where I have put the stochastic.

Rod

Thanks. Looks more like what I expected. I should have noted I use v7. The new version is a bit too complex for this oldtimer. Maybe someday I'll figure out how you do this PCF. Or better yet learn v16.

Bruce, That's simple. I have the stochastic in a chart where each bar represents 3 days.A long time ago you wrote one for a 4day bar chart and it was more complex. Are you sure you understood my query?

Stochastic crossing in a 3 day chart. I have a 3 day chart with a Stochastic 14,5,3 in a window. Can you write me the PCF for the SD5 crossing above the SD3 with the period 14?

Thanks for the explanation. But if I have an MACD 40,30,20  as opposed to 40:20:30 should they not have different results? Your explanation would indicate that the results are the same.