| sttstt |
|
Gold User, Member, TeleChart
|
| Registered User |
|
|
|
|
| Unsure |
|
| Thursday, October 7, 2004 |
| Monday, May 22, 2006 2:00:15 AM |
39
[0.01% of all post / 0.01 posts per day] |
|
Hi Craig,
I had a couple of follow-up question posted in the mutual fund disccusion forum more than a week ago. I have not seen any response at all. Are you guys abandoning the product and discussions all together?
|
[quote=Craig_S]QUOTE
Plot this as a CUSTOM INDICATOR with the CENTER ZERO LINE optino checked.
ABS(C>C30 AND C>C65 AND C>AVGC50)+(C<C30 AND C<C65 AND C<AVGC50)
I tried this. It has some quirkiness. I think I will draw this discussion to a close. Since all I want is a simple visual to capture the condition. I am really not interested in any convoluted expressions to reconstruct an SR flip-flop when a simple addition of a state construct in the PCF language should have been the solution.
For now I will stick with the "cumulative" construct, which has the concept of state.
Thanks both Craig and Jim for the amont of time you spent on this.
|
After re-read the postings, here is what I like to see:
1. the pcf should be as short as possible. A long pcf slows down the computation to an unacceptable crawl.
2. I don't really care about the previous event or state prior to what is displayed on the chart as long as a triggering events get shown as transitions and are visible on the chart. So you can have three states, -1, 0, and +1. 0 being the unkown state so that you don't need to look back, to make it simpler. Then if a triggering event takes place, it will change the state to either -1 or +1. From there on the state is deterministic.
Regards.
|
|
I didn't think it could be done with TC. I threw in the quesiton hoping that I might get lucky. Thanks guys.
|
Looks like that I may have inadvertently created a problem for Craig by using large numbers like 65, 50, and 30. What I intended to do is a simple rate of change where each bar is a daily. I agree with Jim that the interval should not matter. It is just a condition that sets or resets a state. Once a state is set, it stays set indefinitely, until it is reset by the reset condition. Therefore, I don't see why the lookback interval matters.
Unless you plan to somehow create a sequential state machine state with combinatorial logic expressions.
So let's simplify the conditions:
set if c > avgc14 and rsi21 > 50 and tsv16 >50
reset if c < avgc14 and rsi21 <50 and tsv16 <50
or even simpler
set if c>c1 and c1>c2 and c2>c3
reset if c<c1 and c1<c2 and c2<c3
|
Hi Craig,
Sorry for the belated reply. I forgot about the post.
Here is the specification:
set %true to true if c>c30 and c>c65 and c>avgc50
and stay true until
set %true to false if c<c30 and c<c65 and c<avgc50
and stay false until the first condition set it to true again.
Thanks.
|
Hi,
I'd like to plot a set of ratio of two symbols, for example gld vs uso, using custom indicators. I know I can use the relative strength to achieve that. But I want to display a set of predefined ratios, e.g. spx/dia, iwm/iws, qqqq/dia, etc. on the same chart without changing the symbol. Is there a way to do that?
Thanks.
|
|
M & W patterns are based on the 5-point pricing patterns that shape like M (for top) and W (for bottom). The relative positions of these 5 points (highs and lows)result in various M and W classifications.
|
Hi Craig,
Yes. Initially, I was using 4-chart display mode and noticed the problem about 4 days ago. Since then, I have used single chart display with differnt chart templates. It is persistent, not intermittent. When I re-run TC2005, it always displays a particular watchlist with F1 chart template.
I just switched over to a chart template with no custom indicators, it still behaves the same way:
When I use a watchlist that includes IWM, if I jump to IWM, the first time, the cursor will point to IWM, but the chart is not displayed, the 2nd time it will display IWM.
If I click on IWM in a watchlist, TC will terminate. If IWM is already being displayed, click on IWM won't terminate TC.
I do have a lot of watchlists and PCFs. It just occured to me that this roughly occured after I incorporated the RSI with Wilder Smoothing as a PCF using Bruce's formula which takes a lot of time to update the criteria after each new data download. Could you try to create a PCF for rsi21 with wilder's smoothing using the following formula and add a display column in any of the 10 display tabs and see if you can recreate the problem.
Thanks.
100 - (100 / (1 + (((C0 > C1) * (C1 - C0) + 20 / 21 * ((C1 > C2) * (C2 - C1) + 20 / 21 * ((C2 > C3) * (C3 - C2) + 20 / 21 * ((C3 > C4) * (C4 - C3) + 20 / 21 * ((C4 > C5) * (C5 - C4) + 20 / 21 * ((C5 > C6) * (C6 - C5) + 20 / 21 * ((C6 > C7) * (C7 - C6) + 20 / 21 * ((C7 > C8) * (C8 - C7) + 20 / 21 * ((C8 > C9) * (C9 - C8) + 20 / 21 * ((C9 > C10) * (C10 - C9) + 20 / 21 * ((C10 > C11) * (C11 - C10) + 20 / 21 * ((C11 > C12) * (C12 - C11) + 20 / 21 * ((C12 > C13) * (C13 - C12) + 20 / 21 * ((C13 > C14) * (C14 - C13) + 20 / 21 * ((C14 > C15) * (C15 - C14) + 20 / 21 * ((C15 > C16) * (C16 - C15) + 20 / 21 * ((C16 > C17) * (C17 - C16) + 20 / 21 * ((C17 > C18) * (C18 - C17) + 20 / 21 * ((C18 > C19) * (C19 - C18) + 20 / 21 * ((C19 > C20) * (C20 - C19) + 20 / 21 * ((C20 > C21) * (C21 - C20) + 20 / 21 * ((C21 > C22) * (C22 - C21) + 20 / 21 * ((C22 > C23) * (C23 - C22) + 20 / 21 * ((C23 > C24) * (C24 - C23) + 20 / 21 * ((C24 > C25) * (C25 - C24) + 20 / 21 * ((C25 > C26) * (C26 - C25) + 20 / 21 * ((C26 > C27) * (C27 - C26) + 20 / 21 * ((C27 > C28) * (C28 - C27) + 20 / 21 * ((C28 > C29) * (C29 - C28) + 20 / 21 * ((C29 > C30) * (C30 - C29) + 20 / 21 * ((C30 > C31) * (C31 - C30) + 20 / 21 * ((C31 > C32) * (C32 - C31) + 20 / 21 * ((C32 > C33) * (C33 - C32) + 20 / 21 * ((C33 > C34) * (C34 - C33) + 20 / 21 * ((C34 > C35) * (C35 - C34) + 20 / 21 * ((C35 > C36) * (C36 - C35) + 20 / 21 * ((C36 > C37) * (C37 - C36) + 20 / 21 * ((C37 > C38) * (C38 - C37) + 20 / 21 * ((C38 > C39) * (C39 - C38) + 20 / 21 * ((C39 > C40) * (C40 - C39) + 20 / 21 * ((C40 > C41) * (C41 - C40) + 20 / 21 * ((C41 > C42) * (C42 - C41) + 20 / 21 * ((C42 > C43) * (C43 - C42) + 20 / 21 * ((C43 > C44) * (C44 - C43) + 20 / 21 * ((C44 > C45) * (C45 - C44) + 20 / 21 * ((C45 > C46) * (C46 - C45) + 20 / 21 * ((C46 > C47) * (C47 - C46) + 20 / 21 * ((C47 > C48) * (C48 - C47) + 20 / 21 * ((C48 > C49) * (C49 - C48) + 20 / 21 * ((C49 > C50) * (C50 - C49) + 20 / 21 * ((C50 > C51) * (C51 - C50) + 20 / 21 * ((C51 > C52) * (C52 - C51) + 20 / 21 * ((C52 > C53) * (C53 - C52) + 20 / 21 * ((C53 > C54) * (C54 - C53) + 20 / 21 * ((C54 > C55) * (C55 - C54) + 20 / 21 * ((C55 > C56) * (C56 - C55) + 20 / 21 * ((C56 > C57) * (C57 - C56) + 20 / 21 * ((C57 > C58) * (C58 - C57) + 20 / 21 * ((C58 > C59) * (C59 - C58) + 20 / 21 * ((C59 > C60) * (C60 - C59) + 20 / 21 * ((C60 > C61) * (C61 - C60) + 20 / 21 * ((C61 > C62) * (C62 - C61) + 20 / 21 * ((C62 > C63) * (C63 - C62) + 20 / 21 * ((C63 > C64) * (C64 - C63) + 20 / 21 * ((C64 > C65) * (C65 - C64) + 20 / 21 * ((C65 > C66) * (C66 - C65) + 20 / 21 * ((C66 > C67) * (C67 - C66) + 20 / 21 * ((C67 > C68) * (C68 - C67) + 20 / 21 * ((C68 > C69) * (C69 - C68) + 20 / 21 * ((C69 > C70) * (C70 - C69) + 20 / 21 * ((C70 > C71) * (C71 - C70) + 20 / 21 * ((C71 > C72) * (C72 - C71) + 20 / 21 * ((C72 > C73) * (C73 - C72) + 20 / 21 * ((C73 > C74) * (C74 - C73) + 20 / 21 * ((C74 > C75) * (C75 - C74) + 20 / 21 * ((C75 > C76) * (C76 - C75) + 20 / 21 * ((C76 > C77) * (C77 - C76) + 20 / 21 * ((C77 > C78) * (C78 - C77) + 20 / 21 * ((C78 > C79) * (C79 - C78) + 20 / 21 * ((C79 > C80) * (C80 - C79) + 20 / 21 * ((C80 > C81) * (C81 - C80) + 20 / 21 * ((C81 > C82) * (C82 - C81) + 20 / 21 * ((C82 > C83) * (C83 - C82) + 20 / 21 * ((C83 > C84) * (C84 - C83) + 20 / 21 * ((C84 > C85) * (C85 - C84) + 20 / 21 * ((C85 > C86) * (C86 - C85) + 20 / 21 * ((C86 > C87) * (C87 - C86) + 20 / 21 * ((C87 > C88) * (C88 - C87) + 20 / 21 * ((C88 > C89) * (C89 - C88) + 20 / 21 * ((C89 > C90) * (C90 - C89) + 20 / 21 * ((C90 > C91) * (C91 - C90) + 20 / 21 * ((C91 > C92) * (C92 - C91) + 20 / 21 * ((C92 > C93) * (C93 - C92) + 20 / 21 * ((C93 > C94) * (C94 - C93) + 20 / 21 * ((C94 > C95) * (C95 - C94) + 20 / 21 * ((C95 > C96) * (C96 - C95) + 20 / 21 * ((C96 > C97) * (C97 - C96) + 20 / 21 * ((C97 > C98) * (C98 - C97) + 20 / 21 * ((C98 > C99) * (C99 - C98) + 20 / 21 * ((C99 > C100) * (C100 - C99) + 20 / 21 * ((C100 > C101) * (C101 - C100) + 20 / 21 * ((C101 > C102) * (C102 - C101) + 20 / 21 * ((C102 > C103) * (C103 - C102) + 20 / 21 * ((C103 > C104) * (C104 - C103) + 20 / 21 * ((C104 > C105) * (C105 - C104) + 20 / 21 * ((C105 > C106) * (C106 - C105) + 20 / 21 * ((C106 > C107) * (C107 - C106) + 20 / 21 * ((C107 > C108) * (C108 - C107) + 20 / 21 * ((C108 > C109) * (C109 - C108) + 20 / 21 * ((C109 > C110) * (C110 - C109) + 20 / 21 * ((C110 > C111) * (C111 - C110) + 20 / 21 * ((C111 > C112) * (C112 - C111) + 20 / 21 * ((C112 > C113) * (C113 - C112) + 20 / 21 * ((C113 > C114) * (C114 - C113) + 20 / 21 * ((C114 > C115) * (C115 - C114) + 20 / 21 * ((C115 > C116) * (C116 - C115) + 20 / 21 * ((C116 > C117) * (C117 - C116) + 20 / 21 * ((C117 > C118) * (C118 - C117) + 20 / 21 * ((C118 > C119) * (C119 - C118) + 20 / 21 * ((C119 > C120) * (C120 - C119) + 20 / 21 * ((C120 > C121) * (C121 - C120) + 20 / 21 * ((C121 > C122) * (C122 - C121) + 20 / 21 * ((C122 > C123) * (C123 - C122) + 20 / 21 * ((C123 > C124) * (C124 - C123) + 20 / 21 * ((C124 > C125) * (C125 - C124) + 20 / 21 * ((C125 > C126) * (C126 - C125) + 20 / 21 * ((C126 > C127) * (C127 - C126) + 20 / 21 * ((C127 > C128) * (C128 - C127) + 20 / 21 * ((C128 > C129) * (C129 - C128) + 20 / 21 * ((C129 > C130) * (C130 - C129) + 20 / 21 * ((C130 > C131) * (C131 - C130) + 20 / 21 * ((C131 > C132) * (C132 - C131) + 20 / 21 * ((C132 > C133) * (C133 - C132) + 20 / 21 * ((C133 > C134) * (C134 - C133) + 20 / 21 * ((C134 > C135) * (C135 - C134) + 20 / 21 * ((C135 > C136) * (C136 - C135) + 20 / 21 * ((C136 > C137) * (C137 - C136) + 20 / 21 * ((C137 > C138) * (C138 - C137) + 20 / 21 * ((C138 > C139) * (C139 - C138) + 20 / 21 * ((C139 > C140) * (C140 - C139) + 20 / 21 * ((C140 > C141) * (C141 - C140) + 20 / 21 * ((C141 > C142) * (C142 - C141))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) / ((C0 < C1) * (C0 - C1) + 20 / 21 * ((C1 < C2) * (C1 - C2) + 20 / 21 * ((C2 < C3) * (C2 - C3) + 20 / 21 * ((C3 < C4) * (C3 - C4) + 20 / 21 * ((C4 < C5) * (C4 - C5) + 20 / 21 * ((C5 < C6) * (C5 - C6) + 20 / 21 * ((C6 < C7) * (C6 - C7) + 20 / 21 * ((C7 < C8) * (C7 - C8) + 20 / 21 * ((C8 < C9) * (C8 - C9) + 20 / 21 * ((C9 < C10) * (C9 - C10) + 20 / 21 * ((C10 < C11) * (C10 - C11) + 20 / 21 * ((C11 < C12) * (C11 - C12) + 20 / 21 * ((C12 < C13) * (C12 - C13) + 20 / 21 * ((C13 < C14) * (C13 - C14) + 20 / 21 * ((C14 < C15) * (C14 - C15) + 20 / 21 * ((C15 < C16) * (C15 - C16) + 20 / 21 * ((C16 < C17) * (C16 - C17) + 20 / 21 * ((C17 < C18) * (C17 - C18) + 20 / 21 * ((C18 < C19) * (C18 - C19) + 20 / 21 * ((C19 < C20) * (C19 - C20) + 20 / 21 * ((C20 < C21) * (C20 - C21) + 20 / 21 * ((C21 < C22) * (C21 - C22) + 20 / 21 * ((C22 < C23) * (C22 - C23) + 20 / 21 * ((C23 < C24) * (C23 - C24) + 20 / 21 * ((C24 < C25) * (C24 - C25) + 20 / 21 * ((C25 < C26) * (C25 - C26) + 20 / 21 * ((C26 < C27) * (C26 - C27) + 20 / 21 * ((C27 < C28) * (C27 - C28) + 20 / 21 * ((C28 < C29) * (C28 - C29) + 20 / 21 * ((C29 < C30) * (C29 - C30) + 20 / 21 * ((C30 < C31) * (C30 - C31) + 20 / 21 * ((C31 < C32) * (C31 - C32) + 20 / 21 * ((C32 < C33) * (C32 - C33) + 20 / 21 * ((C33 < C34) * (C33 - C34) + 20 / 21 * ((C34 < C35) * (C34 - C35) + 20 / 21 * ((C35 < C36) * (C35 - C36) + 20 / 21 * ((C36 < C37) * (C36 - C37) + 20 / 21 * ((C37 < C38) * (C37 - C38) + 20 / 21 * ((C38 < C39) * (C38 - C39) + 20 / 21 * ((C39 < C40) * (C39 - C40) + 20 / 21 * ((C40 < C41) * (C40 - C41) + 20 / 21 * ((C41 < C42) * (C41 - C42) + 20 / 21 * ((C42 < C43) * (C42 - C43) + 20 / 21 * ((C43 < C44) * (C43 - C44) + 20 / 21 * ((C44 < C45) * (C44 - C45) + 20 / 21 * ((C45 < C46) * (C45 - C46) + 20 / 21 * ((C46 < C47) * (C46 - C47) + 20 / 21 * ((C47 < C48) * (C47 - C48) + 20 / 21 * ((C48 < C49) * (C48 - C49) + 20 / 21 * ((C49 < C50) * (C49 - C50) + 20 / 21 * ((C50 < C51) * (C50 - C51) + 20 / 21 * ((C51 < C52) * (C51 - C52) + 20 / 21 * ((C52 < C53) * (C52 - C53) + 20 / 21 * ((C53 < C54) * (C53 - C54) + 20 / 21 * ((C54 < C55) * (C54 - C55) + 20 / 21 * ((C55 < C56) * (C55 - C56) + 20 / 21 * ((C56 < C57) * (C56 - C57) + 20 / 21 * ((C57 < C58) * (C57 - C58) + 20 / 21 * ((C58 < C59) * (C58 - C59) + 20 / 21 * ((C59 < C60) * (C59 - C60) + 20 / 21 * ((C60 < C61) * (C60 - C61) + 20 / 21 * ((C61 < C62) * (C61 - C62) + 20 / 21 * ((C62 < C63) * (C62 - C63) + 20 / 21 * ((C63 < C64) * (C63 - C64) + 20 / 21 * ((C64 < C65) * (C64 - C65) + 20 / 21 * ((C65 < C66) * (C65 - C66) + 20 / 21 * ((C66 < C67) * (C66 - C67) + 20 / 21 * ((C67 < C68) * (C67 - C68) + 20 / 21 * ((C68 < C69) * (C68 - C69) + 20 / 21 * ((C69 < C70) * (C69 - C70) + 20 / 21 * ((C70 < C71) * (C70 - C71) + 20 / 21 * ((C71 < C72) * (C71 - C72) + 20 / 21 * ((C72 < C73) * (C72 - C73) + 20 / 21 * ((C73 < C74) * (C73 - C74) + 20 / 21 * ((C74 < C75) * (C74 - C75) + 20 / 21 * ((C75 < C76) * (C75 - C76) + 20 / 21 * ((C76 < C77) * (C76 - C77) + 20 / 21 * ((C77 < C78) * (C77 - C78) + 20 / 21 * ((C78 < C79) * (C78 - C79) + 20 / 21 * ((C79 < C80) * (C79 - C80) + 20 / 21 * ((C80 < C81) * (C80 - C81) + 20 / 21 * ((C81 < C82) * (C81 - C82) + 20 / 21 * ((C82 < C83) * (C82 - C83) + 20 / 21 * ((C83 < C84) * (C83 - C84) + 20 / 21 * ((C84 < C85) * (C84 - C85) + 20 / 21 * ((C85 < C86) * (C85 - C86) + 20 / 21 * ((C86 < C87) * (C86 - C87) + 20 / 21 * ((C87 < C88) * (C87 - C88) + 20 / 21 * ((C88 < C89) * (C88 - C89) + 20 / 21 * ((C89 < C90) * (C89 - C90) + 20 / 21 * ((C90 < C91) * (C90 - C91) + 20 / 21 * ((C91 < C92) * (C91 - C92) + 20 / 21 * ((C92 < C93) * (C92 - C93) + 20 / 21 * ((C93 < C94) * (C93 - C94) + 20 / 21 * ((C94 < C95) * (C94 - C95) + 20 / 21 * ((C95 < C96) * (C95 - C96) + 20 / 21 * ((C96 < C97) * (C96 - C97) + 20 / 21 * ((C97 < C98) * (C97 - C98) + 20 / 21 * ((C98 < C99) * (C98 - C99) + 20 / 21 * ((C99 < C100) * (C99 - C100) + 20 / 21 * ((C100 < C101) * (C100 - C101) + 20 / 21 * ((C101 < C102) * (C101 - C102) + 20 / 21 * ((C102 < C103) * (C102 - C103) + 20 / 21 * ((C103 < C104) * (C103 - C104) + 20 / 21 * ((C104 < C105) * (C104 - C105) + 20 / 21 * ((C105 < C106) * (C105 - C106) + 20 / 21 * ((C106 < C107) * (C106 - C107) + 20 / 21 * ((C107 < C108) * (C107 - C108) + 20 / 21 * ((C108 < C109) * (C108 - C109) + 20 / 21 * ((C109 < C110) * (C109 - C110) + 20 / 21 * ((C110 < C111) * (C110 - C111) + 20 / 21 * ((C111 < C112) * (C111 - C112) + 20 / 21 * ((C112 < C113) * (C112 - C113) + 20 / 21 * ((C113 < C114) * (C113 - C114) + 20 / 21 * ((C114 < C115) * (C114 - C115) + 20 / 21 * ((C115 < C116) * (C115 - C116) + 20 / 21 * ((C116 < C117) * (C116 - C117) + 20 / 21 * ((C117 < C118) * (C117 - C118) + 20 / 21 * ((C118 < C119) * (C118 - C119) + 20 / 21 * ((C119 < C120) * (C119 - C120) + 20 / 21 * ((C120 < C121) * (C120 - C121) + 20 / 21 * ((C121 < C122) * (C121 - C122) + 20 / 21 * ((C122 < C123) * (C122 - C123) + 20 / 21 * ((C123 < C124) * (C123 - C124) + 20 / 21 * ((C124 < C125) * (C124 - C125) + 20 / 21 * ((C125 < C126) * (C125 - C126) + 20 / 21 * ((C126 < C127) * (C126 - C127) + 20 / 21 * ((C127 < C128) * (C127 - C128) + 20 / 21 * ((C128 < C129) * (C128 - C129) + 20 / 21 * ((C129 < C130) * (C129 - C130) + 20 / 21 * ((C130 < C131) * (C130 - C131) + 20 / 21 * ((C131 < C132) * (C131 - C132) + 20 / 21 * ((C132 < C133) * (C132 - C133) + 20 / 21 * ((C133 < C134) * (C133 - C134) + 20 / 21 * ((C134 < C135) * (C134 - C135) + 20 / 21 * ((C135 < C136) * (C135 - C136) + 20 / 21 * ((C136 < C137) * (C136 - C137) + 20 / 21 * ((C137 < C138) * (C137 - C138) + 20 / 21 * ((C138 < C139) * (C138 - C139) + 20 / 21 * ((C139 < C140) * (C139 - C140) + 20 / 21 * ((C140 < C141) * (C140 - C141) + 20 / 21 * ((C141 < C142) * (C141 - C142))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))
|
Hi,
I noticed that when I click on IWM in a watchlist. TC2005 will abruptly exit. Also, if I jump to IWM the first time, nothing happens. But it will be displayed the 2nd time I type "j" and IWM. I don't know whether this is peculiar to my system or it is a generic problem. Could you guys try to see if you can replicate the problem and let me know.
Thanks.
|
|