Subscription & data-feed pricing Class schedule

Margin rates Stock & option commissions

Attention: Discussion forums are read-only for extended maintenance until further notice.

 Fun with Logical Operators Rate this Topic:
 Previous Topic · Next Topic Watch this topic · Print this topic ·
Al_Gorithm
 Posted : Saturday, February 9, 2019 1:04:13 PM

Registered User
Joined: 6/30/2017
Posts: 1,227

Happy Monday Bruce,

I got the following PCF from Doug Campbell over at Right Way Options. He shares it freely so there's no copyright or intellectual property issues posting it:

L <= XAVGC8 and C > XAVGC8 and (C < XAVGC3.1) or (C < XAVGC3.2) or (C < XAVGC3.3)

Question: what is the precedence or order of operations for ORs and ANDs in PCFs? Even though coding is my day job, I was always too lazy (lol) to learn the rules so I use enough parentheses to leave absolutely no doubt.

I guess what I'm really asking is, ... wtf is this PCF doing? I have a general idea, but don't want to assume. :)

Thanks ... hope you enjoyed your weekend ... I'm doing laundry ... lol.

HarleyBD
 Posted : Sunday, February 10, 2019 8:12:44 AM
Registered User
Joined: 6/30/2014
Posts: 60

I with you Mr. Gorithm.

I would have to hope for "Please Excuse My Dear Aunt Sally".

(Parentheses, Exponents, Multiplication, Division, Addition, Subtraction)

The issue is with 1/2*x or similar:  does it mean (1/2)*x or does it mean 1/(2*x)?

Regards

bcochrane
 Posted : Sunday, February 10, 2019 9:00:37 AM
Registered User
Joined: 9/17/2010
Posts: 484

I don't know where Doug offered this PCF, but I suspect he means this

L <= XAVGC8 and C > XAVGC8 and ((C < XAVGC3.1) or (C < XAVGC3.2) or (C < XAVGC3.3))

I tried scanning with the PCF as you had it, and with the above formulation, and both returned the same number of stocks (188 from High Cap 1000 today), hence I would conclude that the two are equivalent

Al_Gorithm
 Posted : Sunday, February 10, 2019 4:07:16 PM

Registered User
Joined: 6/30/2017
Posts: 1,227

Thanks to you both for the feedback. I just got home, am overly caffeinated and in need of a nap, but when my brain cells are fully engaged, I'll review your comments.

For now, my back-of-the-napkin interpretation of the logic is ...

Condition returns True if

• L <= XAVGC8
• and C > XAVGC8
• and (C < XAVGC3.1) or (C < XAVGC3.2) or (C < XAVGC3.3)

I'm not sure where on the OCD spectrum I fall, lol, but here's what I think I would code this as ...

(L <= XAVGC8) and (C > XAVGC8) and ((C < XAVGC3.1) or (C < XAVGC3.2) or (C < XAVGC3.3))

think ANDs trump ORs in the precedence heirarchy, so my extra parentheses are probably redundant, but what the h#ll - it makes sense to me. :)

As to the source, Doug has been sharing this PCF for ages in his Right Way Options chat room, and on his site. The most recent reference is a You Tube video he just recorded a few days ago. This PCF is just one condition in my larger trading plan, but the video can be found at ...

Bruce, what do you think?

Bruce_L
 Posted : Monday, February 11, 2019 11:44:13 AM

Worden Trainer

Joined: 10/7/2004
Posts: 65,138

OR does happen before AND in the Personal Criteria Formula Language, so it is possible to write this as just the following.

`L <= XAVGC8 AND C > XAVGC8 AND C < XAVGC3.1 OR C < XAVGC3.2 OR C < XAVGC3.3`

But I would normally add the parentheses for the sake of clarity (I frequently add unnecessary parentheses to my formulas for just this reason).

`L <= XAVGC8 AND C > XAVGC8 AND (C < XAVGC3.1 OR C < XAVGC3.2 OR C < XAVGC3.3)`

You can also shorten this a bit using the `MAX()` function. This might introduce additional clarity as to what it is actually doing or reduce it depending on how you think about these things.

`L <= XAVGC8 AND C > XAVGC8 AND C < MAX(XAVGC3.1, 3)`

-Bruce
Personal Criteria Formulas
TC2000 Support Articles
Al_Gorithm
 Posted : Monday, February 11, 2019 12:49:31 PM

Registered User
Joined: 6/30/2017
Posts: 1,227

Thanks, Bruce! I like this version the best ...

L <= XAVGC8 AND C > XAVGC8 AND (C < XAVGC3.1 OR C < XAVGC3.2 OR C < XAVGC3.3)

It's the closest to the way my brain is wired, and saves several pairs of parentheses over my version. :)

Bruce_L
 Posted : Monday, February 11, 2019 1:11:35 PM

Worden Trainer

Joined: 10/7/2004
Posts: 65,138

You're welcome.

-Bruce
Personal Criteria Formulas
TC2000 Support Articles
Users browsing this topic
Guest-1

 Forum Jump Customer Training & Support - Ask a Trainer - TC2000 version 12/18 - Ask a Trainer - TC2000 version 7 - Ask a Trainer - StockFinder 5.0 - PCFs, EasyScan and Custom Indicators General Discussions - Stock and Market Talk - TC2000 version 12 or 18 - TC2000 version 7 - StockFinder 5.0 - RealCode for StockFinder 5.0 Tutorial Videos - TC2000 version 12 tutorial videos - TC2000 version 7 tutorial videos You cannot post new topics in this forum. You cannot reply to topics in this forum. You cannot delete your posts in this forum. You cannot edit your posts in this forum. You cannot create polls in this forum. You cannot vote in polls in this forum.